1954 Act Security of Tenure: Contracting Out Correctly and Effective Renewal Strategies

Understanding how to contract out security of tenure under the Landlord and Tenant Act 1954 is crucial if you want to manage your business lease effectively. Contracting out means agreeing to exclude the automatic right to renew your lease, but this must be done properly to avoid disputes and loss of protection.

When you know the correct way to handle contracting out, you can plan your renewal strategy more confidently. You will be able to decide if staying protected under the 1954 Act suits your needs or if negotiating a contract without those protections makes more sense for your business. This article will guide you through the key points to help you avoid common pitfalls and secure the best possible outcome for your tenancy.

What Is Security of Tenure Under the Landlord and Tenant Act 1954?

Security of tenure lets you, as a business tenant, stay in your commercial premises after your lease ends. It gives you rights to a new lease unless a landlord has legal reasons to stop this. The Act covers when these rights apply, what protections you have, and the limits landlords can use.

Scope of the 1954 Act for Business Tenancies

The Landlord and Tenant Act 1954 applies mostly to business tenancies in England and Wales. It covers leases for commercial premises used for business purposes. Not all leases fall under this Act; for example, short leases under six months or those where security of tenure is explicitly excluded.

Your tenancy must be a qualifying business tenancy to benefit from the Act. This means the lease is granted for commercial use and excludes certain residential or agricultural leases. You get automatic rights to remain in the property when your fixed term expires, preventing sudden eviction.

Key Tenant and Landlord Rights

Under the Act, you have the right to request a new lease on similar terms if your current lease ends. This protects your business from losing its premises unexpectedly. You must give notice and follow legal steps to claim this right.

The landlord can oppose renewal only on specific grounds, such as the need to redevelop the property or if you have breached lease terms. If the landlord objects, they must prove their case in court. Your right to security of tenure means you have significant protection but not absolute security.

Limitations and Exclusions

Security of tenure is not automatic for every commercial lease. Parties can "contract out" of the Act, meaning they agree that the tenant does not get these protections. This must be done following strict legal procedures before the lease starts.

Also, if your lease lasts less than six months or involves certain types of property (like agricultural land), security of tenure does not apply. You should check your lease carefully to understand if these rights apply to you. Ignoring these limits could leave your business unprotected when the lease ends.

Understanding Contracting Out: Legal Principles and Implications

Contracting out alters the usual rights granted by the 1954 Act to commercial tenants. It affects both landlords’ control over their property and tenants’ security to stay beyond the lease term. You must understand how this process works, when it applies, and its impact on your lease agreement.

The Purpose of Contracting Out

Contracting out allows landlords and tenants to exclude the security of tenure protections under the 1954 Act. This means the tenant does not have the automatic right to renew the lease when it ends. Landlords use contracting out to regain full control of their property without the risk of a tenant staying longer than agreed.

For tenants, contracting out means your lease is for a fixed term only. You should be aware that once the term ends, the landlord can refuse renewal, unless you negotiate otherwise. The process requires strict compliance with legal formalities to be valid. If these are not met, the security of tenure remains in place.

Effects on Tenants’ and Landlords’ Positions

When you contract out of the 1954 Act, your rights change significantly. Tenants lose the right to request a new lease at the end of the term. This can reduce your business’s security, especially if you rely heavily on the location. However, landlords benefit by reducing uncertainty and simplifying letting arrangements.

Both landlords and tenants must follow a formal procedure, which usually involves serving a statutory declaration and agreeing in writing that security of tenure does not apply. Incorrect or incomplete contracting out can lead to disputes, possibly invalidating the contracted-out lease and automatically granting tenants protection.

When Contracting Out Is Suitable

Contracting out is most suitable for short-term leases or when the tenant and landlord want a clear end date for the tenancy without automatic renewal. You should consider it if the tenant’s business model supports flexibility, or if the landlord plans major changes to the property soon.

It is less suitable for tenants seeking long-term security or stable business premises. Before agreeing, you must weigh the risks and benefits carefully. Legal advice is strongly recommended to ensure the contracting out is completed properly to avoid unintended security of tenure rights applying.

Contracting Out Procedure: Getting It Right

When you choose to contract out of the 1954 Act, following the correct legal steps is essential. This ensures the tenant does not gain the statutory right to renew the lease. You must handle notices, declarations, and timing carefully to make the contracting out valid.

Step-by-Step Contracting Out Process

You start by serving a warning notice to the tenant before the lease begins. This notice explains the tenant will lose their security of tenure rights if they sign the lease.

Next, the tenant returns a declaration confirming they understand the consequences. This can be a simple declaration, or if required, a statutory declaration sworn before a solicitor or authorised official.

Once the tenant signs the lease, the completed documents are kept safe. If done correctly, the lease is “contracted out” and the tenant cannot claim renewal rights under the 1954 Act.

Landlord’s Warning Notice Requirements

Your warning notice must be clear and follow legal wording precisely. It needs to warn the tenant that the lease does not provide the usual right to stay after the lease ends.

You must give this notice at least 14 days before the lease starts. It must include specific information such as the impact on security of tenure and advise the tenant to seek independent legal advice.

If the notice is unclear, late, or missing, the contracting out fails. The tenant will then have automatic renewal rights by law.

Tenant’s Declaration Options

The tenant must complete a declaration acknowledging the loss of security of tenure rights.

You can choose between a:

• Simple declaration: Signed by the tenant or their legal representative.

• Statutory declaration: A more formal sworn statement, sometimes required if there is doubt about simple declaration’s sufficiency.

This signed declaration should be returned to you before or when the lease is signed. The declaration confirms that the tenant knew what they were agreeing to.

Timing and Documentary Compliance

Timing is crucial in contracting out. The landlord’s warning notice must be served before the lease starts, usually at least 14 days earlier.

The tenant’s signed declaration must be received before or at the lease signing. If either is late or missing, the lease will not be contracted out, and security of tenure applies.

You must keep all documents safe, as failure to prove proper compliance can result in losing the contracted-out status.

Lease Renewal and Termination Under the 1954 Act

When a business lease comes to an end, the 1954 Act offers you specific rights and procedures to follow. You need to pay close attention to notices, request new leases properly, and understand the reasons a landlord may oppose renewal. Setting fair market rent and negotiating terms wisely is also key to a smooth lease renewal process.

Section 25 Notices and Lease Endings

The landlord must serve you with a Section 25 notice if they want to end the tenancy or oppose a renewal. This notice must be served between six and twelve months before the lease ends. It sets out the landlord’s intentions clearly.

If no Section 25 notice is given, your lease automatically renews under the Act’s protection. The notice can state whether the landlord opposes renewal, and if so, the grounds they will rely on. If the notice is defective or late, you have a right to assume automatic renewal.

Pay close attention to the deadlines and content. Mistakes by the landlord here can affect your rights.

Section 26 Requests for New Leases

To start the renewal process, you must serve a Section 26 notice at least three months before your current lease ends. This notice formally requests a new tenancy.

The notice must describe the premises and the lease terms you are looking for. You can suggest new rent, length, and other conditions. Failure to serve this notice means you may lose your right to automatic renewal.

Once served, both parties enter negotiations. You should use this stage to clarify your renewal goals and propose terms that suit your business needs.

Grounds for Opposing Renewal

Your landlord may refuse renewal but only on specific grounds for opposition set out in the 1954 Act. Common grounds include:

• Landlord intends to redevelop the property.

• Tenant has breached lease terms.

• Landlord wants to occupy the premises personally.

Each ground has strict tests to meet and must be stated in the Section 25 notice. If a landlord cannot prove their ground, you have the right to renew the lease.

Understanding these grounds lets you assess your position and prepare your response.

Market Rent and Negotiating Terms

When renewing, the rent usually resets to the market rent unless agreed otherwise. Market rent means the amount any willing tenant would pay for similar premises.

You should research comparable rents in your area before negotiation. You can ask for lease terms that reduce risk, such as fixed reviews or longer terms.

A good renewal strategy balances rent levels with lease length and break clauses. Negotiating clearly lets you protect your business and avoid costly disputes.

Strategic Considerations for Landlords and Tenants

Understanding how security of tenure works under the 1954 Act is crucial for both landlords and tenants. You need to weigh the effects of lease length, negotiate terms carefully, and consider the legal risks when contracting out. Legal advice plays a key role in guiding your decisions and avoiding disputes.

Negotiating Power and Business Implications

Your negotiating power depends heavily on your business needs and market conditions. Tenants with strong business operations or long-term plans often push for security of tenure. This gives them more confidence to invest in premises.

Landlords, on the other hand, may want more control over their property and prefer shorter leases or contracts that exclude renewal rights. You must balance your business goals with the need to keep the property occupied and profitable.

Clear communication and realistic expectations help both sides. Knowing what each party values most—the tenant’s need for stability or the landlord’s flexibility—can improve your chances of reaching an effective deal.

Impact of Short-Term and Periodic Tenancies

Short-term and periodic tenancies can offer flexibility but may also increase uncertainty. If you are a tenant, a short-term lease can limit your ability to plan long-term or secure financing for improvements.

Landlords benefit from these tenancies by avoiding automatic renewal rights, which can allow more control over future use or the ability to raise rent more often.

However, keep in mind that without security of tenure, tenants risk losing the premises with little time to adjust. You should carefully assess whether periodic tenancies align with your business strategy or property goals.

Risks and Benefits of Contracting Out

Contracting out means excluding the tenant’s right to renew the lease under the 1954 Act. You can opt for this only if certain formal procedures are met, making legal advice essential.

For landlords, contracting out reduces the risk of long-term occupation by unwanted tenants and allows more flexibility to regain possession or redevelop.

Tenants who agree to contract out lose the legal guarantee to stay after the lease ends. This risk may not be worth it if your business relies heavily on location stability.

You must weigh the benefits of flexibility against the security needed to protect business continuity.

Importance of Legal Advice

Given the complexity of the 1954 Act, you should never underestimate the value of specialised legal advice. Lawyers help ensure all contracting out notices, declarations, and formalities are completed properly.

For tenants, legal advice clarifies how renewal strategies could affect your business and helps negotiate better lease terms.

For landlords, expert advice ensures compliance and reduces the risk of costly disputes over tenancy rights.

Legal guidance is crucial to making informed decisions and protecting your interests in commercial leasing.

Reform and the Future of Security of Tenure

The future of security of tenure under the 1954 Act involves careful consideration of the Law Commission’s ongoing work and the practical effects of any changes. You need to understand what reforms may come, how they could affect your lease, and how to prepare strategies for renewing or contracting out of tenancy protections.

Law Commission Consultations

The Law Commission began exploring reforms to the 1954 Act by consulting stakeholders in late 2024. They asked for views on keeping, abolishing, or altering security of tenure rights for business tenants. Over 160 responses showed mixed opinions but a clear interest in modernising the law.

The Commission’s interim statement from June 2025 confirmed that security of tenure remains relevant and should continue. They support keeping the contracting-out option, which lets parties agree to exclude these protections in certain leases. This indicates that your ability to negotiate contracts excluding or limiting tenure will still play a key role.

The Commission’s provisional conclusions will guide further work. So, you should expect some reforms but not a complete overhaul of how security of tenure works under the 1954 Act.

Potential Legislative Changes

While the fundamental principles of security of tenure will remain, some changes are likely to update who benefits and how contracting-out works. The Law Commission is considering refining the list of tenancy types excluded from the Act’s protection. This could clarify which leases you can contract out of and which cannot.

You might see changes to improve transparency around contracting-in and contracting-out processes, making it easier to understand your rights before entering a lease. The overarching goal is a fairer system reflecting modern commercial markets.

These reforms will not remove your right to renew a business lease but may affect how and when you negotiate terms. Staying informed on these legislative developments will help you plan your leasing strategy effectively.

Adapting to Evolving Commercial Leasing

Given that security of tenure will stay but reforms are ahead, you need to adapt your approach to lease negotiations and renewals. If you choose to contract out, ensure agreements are clear and comply with any new rules.

You should also review renewal strategies to align with evolving requirements. For instance, you may want to negotiate flexibility in break clauses or review rent review terms in light of updated contracting-out rules.

Being proactive is vital. Knowing the Law Commission’s direction helps you avoid surprises and secure tenancy agreements that suit your business needs while respecting the 1954 Act’s framework.

Looking for trusted legal experts? Athi Law offers experienced business immigration solicitors to support your company’s global talent needs, specialists in commercial conveyancing to protect your property transactions, and reliable independent legal advice for mortgage agreements. We also assist with immigration for parents, helping reunite families with care. Speak to us today!